How Does Cognitive Warfare Affect Human Trust?

Published on
Read: 3 min
How Does Cognitive Warfare Affect Human Trust? © The Strategist

In November 2026, the Indian technology publication VARINDIA put trust at the heart of cognitive warfare. As artificial intelligence makes it easier to imitate voices and faces, people seeking to influence public opinion can exploit the uncertainty surrounding what audiences see and hear. Two studies, one on reactions to a political deepfake in the United Kingdom and the other on false denials in the United States, show how that uncertainty can shape trust in news and political judgement.

When seeing leaves room for doubt

Cognitive warfare seeks to influence how people interpret events and make decisions. A deepfake can serve that purpose by exploiting a familiar shortcut in human judgement. When we recognise a face or a voice, we tend to treat that recognition as evidence of who is speaking. A fabricated recording can borrow the authority of a public figure or the familiarity of someone we know. It can also leave us wondering whether a genuine recording deserves the same degree of confidence we once gave it.

In a study published in 2020, Cristian Vaccari and Andrew Chadwick randomly assigned 2,005 British participants to watch one of three versions of a BuzzFeed video. Two groups saw excerpts, lasting four or 26 seconds, in which Barack Obama appeared to insult Donald Trump. The third group saw the full video, which revealed that the comedian Jordan Peele was impersonating Obama. The researchers then asked participants whether Obama had actually made the remark and assessed how much trust they placed in news on social media.

The misleading excerpts were more likely to leave viewers unsure than to persuade them that Obama had made the remark. That uncertainty was associated with lower trust in news on social media. The finding matters because it captures an effect that a simple measure of belief would miss. A viewer who comes away unsure may withhold judgement about the clip and become more sceptical of other information encountered on the same platforms. In this experiment, the doubt extended beyond the words attributed to Obama.

How politicians can benefit from doubt

The possibility of fabrication also gives politicians facing scrutiny grounds to challenge authentic reporting. Kaylyn Jackson Schiff, Daniel Schiff and Natália S. Bueno use the term “liar’s dividend” for the political benefit a public figure can gain by falsely claiming that damaging information is fabricated. For an audience trying to decide what happened, that claim introduces a second question. Alongside the politician’s conduct, the credibility of the report itself becomes a matter of dispute.

The researchers conducted five experiments involving more than 15,000 American adults. Participants were given accounts of real political scandals and presented with hypothetical responses from the politicians involved. Across the experiments, the researchers compared false claims of misinformation with responses such as remaining silent or apologising. A false denial could help a politician retain more support than either of those alternatives. The study also examined two ways a denial could work, by creating uncertainty about the facts or by rallying existing supporters.

The effect depended on the evidence participants saw. False denials were effective against written accounts but largely ineffective against video evidence. The US researchers also detected no overall decline in trust in the media. That finding helps define the reach of the “liar’s dividend”. A politician may benefit from casting doubt on a single report even if the people who read it continue to trust the media in general. The British study measured trust in news on social media after exposure to manipulated footage, while the US study tested reactions to a politician’s response to damaging reporting.

What gives audiences grounds for trust?

When a familiar voice or face can be imitated, people need other ways to establish where a message came from. Within an organisation, this becomes a practical question when a message asks someone to make a consequential decision. VARINDIA highlights the value of confirming such instructions through an independent channel. The recipient can then base a decision on confirmation from an identifiable source, even if the recording itself remains difficult to assess.

For news organisations and public institutions, the same question arises when footage circulates without its original context. Giving audiences access to the full recording, identifying its source and explaining when and where it was made can help them assess what it shows. These details also give other people something concrete to check. The distinction matters especially when two sides disagree over whether a clip is authentic and each asks the public to accept its account.

The impact of cognitive warfare on trust can therefore take more than one form. A manipulated clip can make viewers less sure of the information they encounter, while a false denial can change how they judge a particular scandal. The studies show that these effects vary with the material people see and the judgement they are asked to make. For journalists, institutions and citizens, the question is whether people can still establish a shared account of what happened, even when they disagree about what it means.

Leave a Comment

Share to...